I'll be honest Requiem was amazing, till the last chapter. It was a clear five stars till I got to the end. Nothing was answered, I don't know about some people but I like closure in a book especially in the final book, that is why its called a conclusion....A lot of people died, she got reunited with Gracie and Alex then a stupid poem to end it? Julian didn't even serve a purpose in this series just a stupid obstetrical nothing else, so why did she even create him? ugh, I'll end my rant there. So that's why it only earned a 3.5 out of 5. I wish